"Leuchtender Sternendrache" gibt es nicht, ich vermute mal du meinst den Sternenstaubdrachen.
Wenn Skill Drain liegt, dann kannst du beide Effekte von Sternenstaubdrache benutzen.
Begründung: Während der Auflösung des Effektes liegt der Sternenstaubdrache auf dem Friedhof und nicht auf dem Feld!
Nein, er meint Savior Star Dragon, der erst in ein paar Wochen rauskommt.
Wenn Skill Drain liegt, sollte er nicht zurück ins Deck gehen. Allerdings kannst du dann auch nur den 1. Effekt des Drachen nutzen (also in tributen, um was zu negieren und alle gegnerischen Karten zerstören).
Btw is es sehr sinnvoll nach Rulings zu Karten zu fragen, die noch nicht mal erhältich sind...
da der effekt bekannt ist wirds ja wohl n logischer ruling geben das man daraus ableitet.
Btw ist das nicht n bisle sehr gut?
mein freund will so ein deck bauen und da wollt ich halt fragen ob es so funktioniert..
Alle bekannten Rulings dazu:
Spoiler:
Tributing "Majestic Star Dragon" is a cost to activate its effect which negates the activation of the effect of a Spell, Trap, or Effect Monster and destroys all cards your opponent controls.[1]
The effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" which negates the effect of an opponent's monster until the End Phase targets one of your opponent's monsters.[1]
The effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" which returns it to the Extra Deck during the End Phase targets one "Stardust Dragon" in your Graveyard. The Special Summoning part of this effect resolves consecutively.[1]
If "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effect of "Victory Viper XX03", then when "Majestic Star Dragon" destroys a monster by battle, you can activate the effect from "Victory Viper XX03" which Special Summons an "Option Token". However, there is no "Victory Viper XX03" on the field, so the Special Summoned "Option Token" is immediately destroyed.[2]
If your "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effect of "Morphtronic Celfon" while "Morphtronic Celfon" is in Attack Position, then you may activate either the "● While in Attack Position:" or the "● While in Defense Position:" effect from "Morphtronic Celfon", as appropriate for the Battle Position of "Majestic Star Dragon".[3]
If a monster's effects are already being negated by an effect like "Forbidden Chalice" or "Debris Dragon", then you may not choose it as a target for the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" which negates the effects of a monster.[4]
"Majestic Star Dragon" can only activate the effect of a negated monster only once. If "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effect of a monster like "Neo-Spacian Dark Panther" or "Phantom of Chaos" and then uses the negated monster's effect to gain the effects of another Effect Monster, then you cannot activate the effect of the other Effect Monster because you already activated the effect of "Phantom of Chaos".[5]
If "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effect of a monster, then if the monster's effect requires an activation cost, then you cannot activate that effect unless you pay the activation cost.[6]
If "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effect of a monster, then if the monster's effect can only be activating at a specific time, then you cannot activate that effect unless you are activating it at the proper time.[6]
You can only activate the effect of a negated monster as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" during the same turn in which the monster's effects were negated.[7]
The effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" which negates the effects of an Effect Monster is an effect which activates and starts a Chain Link. "Divine Wrath" may be Chained to this effect to negate its activation and destroy "Majestic Star Dragon".[8]
You may not select a Gemini Monster that is being treated as a Normal Monster as a target for the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" which negates effects. If "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effect of a Gemini Monster like "Gigaplant" or "Doom Shaman", then the Gemini Monster no longer has its effect which is listed by the "●", so therefore "Majestic Star Dragon" may not activate the Gemini Monster's effect which is listed by the "●".[9]
If a monster whose effects are negated by "Majestic Star Dragon" is no longer face-up on the field, then you may still activate the monster's effect as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon", as long as it is still the same turn in which the effects were negated.[10]
The effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" which returns it to the Extra Deck during the End Phase and Special Summons "Stardust Dragon" is mandatory, so it will activate even if "Vanity's Fiend" or "Jowgen the Spiritualist" are face-up on the field. In this case, "Majestic Star Dragon" will return itself to the Extra Deck, but "Stardust Dragon" will not be Special Summoned.[11]
If the ATK of "Majestic Star Dragon" is increased because it negated and then activated the effect of "Card Trooper", then when it is affected by "Skill Drain", the ATK of "Majestic Star Dragon" will return to its original value.[12]
A monster whose effects are negated by "Majestic Star Dragon" only has its effects negated while the monster is face-up on the field. If "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effects of a monster like "Sangan", then when "Sangan" is sent to the Graveyard its effect of adding a card from the Deck to the hand is not negated.[13]
You may Synchro Summon "Majestic Star Dragon" by using a "Stardust Dragon" which is being treated as a Tuner Monster. If a non-Tuner Monster has its name treated as "Majestic Dragon" and "Stardust Dragon" is being treated as a Tuner Monster, then you may Synchro Summon "Majestic Star Dragon" by using the non-Tuner "Majestic Star Dragon", the Tuner "Stardust Dragon", and one other non-Tuner Monster as Synchro Material Monsters.[14]
The effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" which returns it to the Extra Deck during the End Phase targets one "Stardust Dragon" in your Graveyard. If there is no "Stardust Dragon" in your Graveyard, then this effect still activates; "Majestic Star Dragon" is still returned to the Extra Deck, but no "Stardust Dragon" is Special Summoned.[15]
"Majestic Star Dragon" can only activate the effect of an opponent's monster as its own effect if "Majestic Star Dragon" is face-up on the field. Thus, if "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effects of a monster like "Sangan" whose effect activates in the Graveyard, then when "Majestic Star Dragon" is sent to the Graveyard you may not activate the effect of "Sangan" as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon".[16]
If "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effects of a monster like "King Tiger Wanghu" with a mandatory Trigger Effect, then when a monster with 1400 ATK or less is Normal Summoned or Special Summoned the controller of "Majestic Star Dragon" may choose whether or not the effect of "King Tiger Wanghu" activates as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon". If a monster is Normal Summoned or Special Summoned at Chain Link 2 or higher, then after the Chain finishes resolving you may activate the effect of "King Tiger Wanghu" as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon", without missing the timing.[17]
In general, the effect "Once, you may activate an effect which belongs to the negated monster as the effect of this card." of "Majestic Star Dragon" may only activate an effect which starts a Chain Link. Thus, you can only activate a negated monster's Ignition Effect, Trigger Effect, or Quick Effect as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon".[18]
If the activation timing of an effect is not correct, then you cannot activate the effect as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon".[18]
If a Spell or Trap Card is face-up on the field and its effect activates, then the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" may be activated in Chain to the effect to negate its activation and destroy all cards your opponent controls.[19]
If the effect of "G.B. Hunter" is active, then during the End Phase the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" to return itself to the Extra Deck still activates. However, "Majestic Star Dragon" cannot be returned to the Extra Deck, so when resolving the effect "Majestic Star Dragon" is not returned to the Extra Deck and "Stardust Dragon" is not Special Summoned.[20]
If "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effects of a monster like "ArmedDragonLV5" with multiple effects, then you can activate the effects of the negated monster as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" a total of once. Thus, if you activate the effect "ArmedDragonLV5" which destroys a monster as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon", then later on you cannot activate the effect of "ArmedDragonLV5" which Special Summons "ArmedDragon LV7" as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon".[21]
The effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" which returns it to the Extra Deck and Special Summons "Stardust Dragon" during the End Phase is a mandatory effect. The player must activate the effect; he cannot choose to not activate the effect and leave "Majestic Star Dragon" on the field.[22]
Nur noch mal zur allgemeinem Verständnis, Also so du MUST ihn ins extra deck legen
Tributing "Majestic Star Dragon" is a cost to activate its effect which negates the activation of the effect of a Spell, Trap, or Effect Monster and destroys all cards your opponent controls.[1]
The effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" which negates the effect of an opponent's monster until the End Phase targets one of your opponent's monsters.[1]
The effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" which returns it to the Extra Deck during the End Phase targets one "Stardust Dragon" in your Graveyard. The Special Summoning part of this effect resolves consecutively.[1]
If "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effect of "Victory Viper XX03", then when "Majestic Star Dragon" destroys a monster by battle, you can activate the effect from "Victory Viper XX03" which Special Summons an "Option Token". However, there is no "Victory Viper XX03" on the field, so the Special Summoned "Option Token" is immediately destroyed.[2]
If your "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effect of "Morphtronic Celfon" while "Morphtronic Celfon" is in Attack Position, then you may activate either the "● While in Attack Position:" or the "● While in Defense Position:" effect from "Morphtronic Celfon", as appropriate for the Battle Position of "Majestic Star Dragon".[3]
If a monster's effects are already being negated by an effect like "Forbidden Chalice" or "Debris Dragon", then you may not choose it as a target for the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" which negates the effects of a monster.[4]
"Majestic Star Dragon" can only activate the effect of a negated monster only once. If "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effect of a monster like "Neo-Spacian Dark Panther" or "Phantom of Chaos" and then uses the negated monster's effect to gain the effects of another Effect Monster, then you cannot activate the effect of the other Effect Monster because you already activated the effect of "Phantom of Chaos".[5]
If "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effect of a monster, then if the monster's effect requires an activation cost, then you cannot activate that effect unless you pay the activation cost.[6]
If "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effect of a monster, then if the monster's effect can only be activating at a specific time, then you cannot activate that effect unless you are activating it at the proper time.[6]
You can only activate the effect of a negated monster as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" during the same turn in which the monster's effects were negated.[7]
The effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" which negates the effects of an Effect Monster is an effect which activates and starts a Chain Link. "Divine Wrath" may be Chained to this effect to negate its activation and destroy "Majestic Star Dragon".[8]
You may not select a Gemini Monster that is being treated as a Normal Monster as a target for the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" which negates effects. If "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effect of a Gemini Monster like "Gigaplant" or "Doom Shaman", then the Gemini Monster no longer has its effect which is listed by the "●", so therefore "Majestic Star Dragon" may not activate the Gemini Monster's effect which is listed by the "●".[9]
If a monster whose effects are negated by "Majestic Star Dragon" is no longer face-up on the field, then you may still activate the monster's effect as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon", as long as it is still the same turn in which the effects were negated.[10]
The effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" which returns it to the Extra Deck during the End Phase and Special Summons "Stardust Dragon" is mandatory, so it will activate even if "Vanity's Fiend" or "Jowgen the Spiritualist" are face-up on the field. In this case, "Majestic Star Dragon" will return itself to the Extra Deck, but "Stardust Dragon" will not be Special Summoned.[11]
If the ATK of "Majestic Star Dragon" is increased because it negated and then activated the effect of "Card Trooper", then when it is affected by "Skill Drain", the ATK of "Majestic Star Dragon" will return to its original value.[12]
A monster whose effects are negated by "Majestic Star Dragon" only has its effects negated while the monster is face-up on the field. If "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effects of a monster like "Sangan", then when "Sangan" is sent to the Graveyard its effect of adding a card from the Deck to the hand is not negated.[13]
You may Synchro Summon "Majestic Star Dragon" by using a "Stardust Dragon" which is being treated as a Tuner Monster. If a non-Tuner Monster has its name treated as "Majestic Dragon" and "Stardust Dragon" is being treated as a Tuner Monster, then you may Synchro Summon "Majestic Star Dragon" by using the non-Tuner "Majestic Star Dragon", the Tuner "Stardust Dragon", and one other non-Tuner Monster as Synchro Material Monsters.[14]
The effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" which returns it to the Extra Deck during the End Phase targets one "Stardust Dragon" in your Graveyard. If there is no "Stardust Dragon" in your Graveyard, then this effect still activates; "Majestic Star Dragon" is still returned to the Extra Deck, but no "Stardust Dragon" is Special Summoned.[15]
"Majestic Star Dragon" can only activate the effect of an opponent's monster as its own effect if "Majestic Star Dragon" is face-up on the field. Thus, if "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effects of a monster like "Sangan" whose effect activates in the Graveyard, then when "Majestic Star Dragon" is sent to the Graveyard you may not activate the effect of "Sangan" as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon".[16]
If "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effects of a monster like "King Tiger Wanghu" with a mandatory Trigger Effect, then when a monster with 1400 ATK or less is Normal Summoned or Special Summoned the controller of "Majestic Star Dragon" may choose whether or not the effect of "King Tiger Wanghu" activates as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon". If a monster is Normal Summoned or Special Summoned at Chain Link 2 or higher, then after the Chain finishes resolving you may activate the effect of "King Tiger Wanghu" as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon", without missing the timing.[17]
In general, the effect "Once, you may activate an effect which belongs to the negated monster as the effect of this card." of "Majestic Star Dragon" may only activate an effect which starts a Chain Link. Thus, you can only activate a negated monster's Ignition Effect, Trigger Effect, or Quick Effect as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon".[18]
If the activation timing of an effect is not correct, then you cannot activate the effect as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon".[18]
If a Spell or Trap Card is face-up on the field and its effect activates, then the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" may be activated in Chain to the effect to negate its activation and destroy all cards your opponent controls.[19]
If the effect of "G.B. Hunter" is active, then during the End Phase the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" to return itself to the Extra Deck still activates. However, "Majestic Star Dragon" cannot be returned to the Extra Deck, so when resolving the effect "Majestic Star Dragon" is not returned to the Extra Deck and "Stardust Dragon" is not Special Summoned.[20]
If "Majestic Star Dragon" negates the effects of a monster like "ArmedDragonLV5" with multiple effects, then you can activate the effects of the negated monster as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" a total of once. Thus, if you activate the effect "ArmedDragonLV5" which destroys a monster as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon", then later on you cannot activate the effect of "ArmedDragonLV5" which Special Summons "ArmedDragon LV7" as the effect of "Majestic Star Dragon".[21]
The effect of "Majestic Star Dragon" which returns it to the Extra Deck and Special Summons "Stardust Dragon" during the End Phase is a mandatory effect. The player must activate the effect; he cannot choose to not activate the effect and leave "Majestic Star Dragon" on the field.[22]
Nur noch mal zur allgemeinem Verständnis, Also so du MUST ihn ins extra deck legen
Aus dem von dir markiertem geht jetzt nur hervor, dass der Effekt nicht optional ist. Ich hab noch was in deinem Post markiert, aus dem hervorgeht, dass es keine Kosten sind, ihn ins Extradeck zu legen => Skill Drain negiert den Effekt, dass er ins Extradeck zurück muss, sofern Skill Drain beim Resolve noch auf dem Feld liegt. Das ist vergleichbar mit der Situation mit dem G.B. Jäger.
Ich weiß jetzt nicht, wie du es gemeint hast, man kann aus deinem Post nämlich auch entnehmen (wenn man denn möchte), dass er bei offenem Skill Drain ins Deck gelegt wird.
When your opponent activates the effect of a Spell, Trap or Effect Monster, you can Tribute this card to negate it, and destroy all cards your opponent controls. Once per turn, negate the effect(s) of 1 face-up monster your opponent controls until the End Phase. That monster's effect(s) can be treated as this card's effect and can be activated once. Return this card to the Extra Deck during the End Phase, and Special Summon 1 "Stardust Dragon" from your Graveyard.
Wenn mein Englisch nicht vollkommen im Eimer ist, steht im Effekttext nix von "wieder kommen"... also nein, anders als sein kleiner Bruder kommt der Majestic NICHT vom Friedhof zurück.
Zur eigentlichen Frage: Skill Drain negiert den Effekt, dass er ins Extradeck zurück muss, sofern Skill Drain beim Resolve noch auf dem Feld liegt.
Leuchtender Sternendrache
~ Das Deck ist belanglos - Deine Taten krönen dich ~
(slay) - I can
(fly) ~
Zitat von -censored-
Forumregeln
